Journalism understandably prioritizes the new: it’s called “news” for a reason. But the best journalism puts the new in context: only by knowing that temperatures were significantly lower throughout civilization’s 10,000 year history can one grasp how much higher they are today, and why that alarms scientists so much.
Policy ideas also have a history, as Fiona Harvey, an environment editor for The Guardian, explained yesterday: Harvey’s piece celebrates the paradigm-shifting work of Nicholas Stern, who 20 years ago this week published a report that, Harvey wrote, “upended [the] conventional wisdom among economists” that climate change was not a major problem. For example, William Nordhaus argued in 2018, the year he won the Nobel Prize in Economics, that economies would shrink only 8.5% if global temperatures rose 6 degrees C. What Nordhaus ignored, Harvey tartly notes, is that “at 6C widespread famine could leave billions of people, in economic terms, suboptimally productive. Or, as the rest of us might say, dead.”
Read Harvey’s piece in full, below. Covering Climate Now partners who’d like their work considered for republication here should email CCNow’s Executive Editor, Anna Hiatt, at anna@coveringclimatenow.org with pitches.
Saving the only planet we have makes good economic sense. There is, after all, no money to be made on a dead Earth. There may be costs involved now, but they are worth paying to protect our children from certain destruction.
These propositions seem self-evident now. But two decades ago, mainstream economists had very different ideas. They had proved that the climate crisis would be a mere economic blip, easily absorbed by growing economies and therefore not worth spending money on. In their accounting, they considered ice caps and glaciers functionally worthless, that trees only add to GDP when they are cut down, and that a livable climate shouldn’t even merit a line on a spreadsheet.
What changed? Twenty years ago this week an earth-shaking report was published by Nicholas Stern, a former World Bank chief economist turned adviser to Gordon Brown. His review, The Economics of Climate Change, upended conventional wisdom among economists and dragged them into a new century. It set out, for the first time, in clear and bold terms, why investing in a low-carbon future makes economic sense.
The Stern review, in 700 dense pages full of graphs and data, is a model of transformative thinking. Using standard economic tools and methods, and in ways that other mainstream economists could understand, Stern made three key, and at the time radical, conclusions: that the costs of inaction on the climate were greater than the costs of action; that the climate crisis was a market failure; and that economic growth was compatible with cutting greenhouse gas emissions.
Stern’s crucial insight, the revolutionary idea on which his whole thesis turned, was that future generations have as much right to be born as we did. Traditional economics mistrusts anything that could happen in the future, applying a “discount rate” to it. Likely future profits are reckoned as lower in value than those of the present, as are likely future losses.
That might make sense when compiling companies’ accounts, as it prevents them over-selling themselves on optimistic assumptions. But applying a discount rate where the climate is concerned is a gross distortion – effectively, it means future lives are assigned less value, and so taking actions now that protect children when they grow up are made to appear uneconomic.
To gauge how startling this proposal was at the time, consider William Nordhaus, former professor of economics at Yale, whose work was the previous standard for climate economics. He confidently asserted in the early 1990s that countries should budget for “moderate” global heating, of about 3C to 4C above preindustrial levels, because below that the cost of cutting greenhouse gas emissions would outweigh the damage of climate change. In order to reach these conclusions, Nordhaus’s work relied on the same “discounting” assigned to future damage and future lives that Stern set out to challenge.
The vitriol poured on Stern by fellow economists – including Nordhaus – was intense. I covered it at the time for the Financial Times, and I remember the spluttering outrage of traditional economists, fuming that the discount rate – a central tenet of Treasury forecasting around the world – could be meddled with. The ethical point appeared to elude them. Ethics have little place in GDP.
But Stern stuck to his analysis, and in the 20 years since it has been found sound – if anything, he underestimated both the rapidity of heating and economic consequences, and overestimated the cost of renewable energy. Stern’s work liberated many governments: they could now justify bold climate strategies to investors, aid donors and the ever-present bond markets. Conversely, laggard administrations could be challenged at the ballot box and, increasingly, in court.
Today, Stern says, if he were re-doing the review, he would place more emphasis on the role of nature, as the collapse of biodiversity around the world is a key economic and national security threat that has been grossly underestimated, and neglected as a result.
It might seem, in 2026, as if Stern has won the argument. But traditional economic approaches to the climate refuse to go away. In 2018, even after a deluge of science showing that 3C heating would leave coastal cities under water and swathes of agricultural land as desert, Nordhaus published a paper claiming that 3C would reduce global GDP by just 2.1%, and even a 6C increase would incur just 8.5% GDP loss. However, other climate scientists have indicated that at 6C widespread famine could leave billions of people, in economic terms, suboptimally productive. Or, as the rest of us might say, dead.
In 2018, Nordhaus was awarded the Nobel prize. His work on the climate was prominent in the citation and his prize lecture. In hundreds of universities around the world, economists are still being trained today in those same traditional growth models he used. And sunny predictions that the climate crisis could shave just a few per cent off GDP are still in use, shockingly, among governments, businesses and international institutions, even as temperatures shatter records and the supercharged El Niño threatens trillions of dollars in damages.
The results are plain to see: governments refusing to act, markets over-valuing fossil fuel companies, investors punishing businesses that dare to prepare for a low-carbon world. Many insurance companies, supposedly the enforcers of probity in capital markets, are alleged to knowingly be fudging their figures to massage climate risk away, as the Guardian revealed this month.
If we are to have a thriving future economy, as well as a living planet and robust human societies, we need a new system of economics that values these things. Stern showed the way. Twenty years later, the rest of the world must catch up.
From Us
Last Spots! Free Training for US-Based Journalists From All Beats. CCNow’s The Climate Newsroom is a free, Zoom-based training program designed for reporters, producers, and editors, working in print, digital, radio, TV, and social media — with or without experience covering climate. Applications are due TOMORROW, Friday, October 30. We’ll get started the following week. Apply now.
Climate on the Ballot: How the Midterms Could Advance State-level Climate Policy. Twelve competitive governor’s races and a few dozen legislative seats could result in new Democratic trifectas — and, with them, opportunities to advance climate policy.
- New Tool: How Climate Impacts Rising Costs in Your Area. Affordability is a top concern for voters, and nationwide climate change is pushing up the cost of living. This searchable tool helps journalists in the US make this connection locally. Public opinion data and congressional voting records show how voters’ climate concerns compare with how their representatives vote on environmental legislation.
WATCH: Why COP31 Could Surprise Us. Dig into the fast-approaching UN climate summit in Antalya, Turkey with a panel of climate luminaries, including Kumi Naidoo, President of the Fossil Fuel Treaty Initiative; Johan Rockström, Director of the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impacts Research; Ana Toni, CEO and Executive Director for last year’s COP30; and Stientje van Veldhoven, Minister of Climate and Green Growth for the Netherlands.
Noteworthy Stories
Lula’s triumph. Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva’s re-election this week — an upset, given polling which had indicated his defeat — has climate advocates hopeful that the country might actually meet its goal of zero deforestation in the Amazon by 2030, as well as advance a Lula-backed rainforest protection fund. By Sebastian Rodriguez for Climate Home News…
- On Monday, the Netherlands announced it would contribute $500 million over 10 years to the Tropical Forests Forever Facility. By Rafael Cardoso for Agência Brasil…
- For Indigenous communities, Brazil’s election results are a mixed bag. Though Lula won re-election, his opponent’s right-wing Liberal Party gained ground in the National Congress, which will “[make] it much harder for Lula to advance his Indigenous and environmental agendas.” By Joseph Lee for Grist…
50,000 deaths. Heatwaves in Europe this summer contributed to an estimated 50,000 deaths across the continent, marking the most deadly season for heat mortality on record, according to new research. Attracta Mooney and Ian Johnston for The Financial Times…
Canada on trial. More than a dozen young Canadians are testifying in court this week against the country’s government, calling its climate policies inadequate and a violation of their constitutional rights. By Dana Drugmand for Inside Climate News…
Fossil gas. A 2026 Data for Progress poll revealed that 50% of Americans think that natural gas is a form of clean energy. It is not. In a new podcast, Heated’s Emily Atkin unpacks why so many people believe the myth.
Enabling pollution. President Donald Trump announced earlier this week that he is “terminating” Biden-era methane rules that required oil and gas companies to plug methane leaks at their facilities. Methane is among the most potent forms of carbon emissions and a hazard to human health. By Sara Sneath for The Guardian…
‘Huge mistake.’ John Podesta, the top climate advisor in the Biden White House, says the Senate’s bipartisan permitting reform bill (BAAJA) is generally good policy, but warned that Democrats’ concession on public lands should be reversed or else hands Trump “a loaded Howitzer” in his administration’s war against clean energy projects. By Jael Holzman for Heatmap…
Quote of the Week
“We should now be moving in a way that we understand the challenge of climate emergency is not just a failure of our environmental approach; it’s a failure of our economic system, our energy system, our transport system and so on.”
– Kumi Naidoo, Director of The Fossil Fuel Initiative in CCNow’s “Why COP31 Could Surprise Us” live conversation.
New Science, Resources & Events
- “Greenhouse gas levels once again reach record high” (WMO)
- “Nearly half of shallow-water corals face an ‘elevated risk of extinction’ due to climate change” (Nature)
- “Protecting Health in the Age of Climate Disinformation” [World Health Organization (WHO) and the Global Climate and Health Alliance (GCHA)]
- “Beyond the Funding Gap: A Global Assessment of the Loss of USAID’s Environment and Climate Programming” (One Earth Partners)
- “Coal Costs Americans: tracking expensive giveaways to coal plants” (Environmental Defense Fund)
- “Investigating the Climate Crisis? Explore These Six GIJN Guides” (Global Investigative Journalism Network)
- “Super-rich get ‘double dividend’ from causes and costs of climate crisis, report finds” (Jonathan Watts, The Guardian)
- “Experts urge ‘global health emergency’ as climate harms accelerate” (Josh Axelrod, DW)
- “Everything You Could Possibly Want to Know About El Niño” (Judson Jones, Chico Harlan and Raymond Zhong, The New York Times)
- “Over 400,000 Climate Voters Have Already Voted in Their First Midterm Election” (Environmental Voter Project)
Jobs, Etc.
Jobs. New Hampshire Public Radio is hiring a Climate Change Reporter (Concord, N.H.). Scientific American is hiring a News Intern (remote, New York, NY). Inside Climate News is hiring a Senior Editor (remote, American West preferred). WIRED is hiring a Features Editor (New York, N.Y.). The Environmental Law & Policy Center (ELPC) is seeking a full-time Communications Writer (Chicago, Ill.). SciLine is hiring an On-Call Reporter (Remote). The Audubon Society is hiring a Senior Writer, Executive Communications (Washington, D.C.) and an Editorial Fellow (New York, N.Y.). Bloomberg Industry Group is hiring a News Team Lead – Environment (Arlington, Va.). Heatmap is hiring a Senior Editor (remote). Columbia University’s Graduate School of Journalism is hiring a David Laventhol Visiting Professor (New York, N.Y.). The Council on Foreign Relations is hiring a Research Associate, Energy and Climate (New York, N.Y.). Floodlight is hiring an Operations and Development Coordinator (remote). POLITICO is hiring an Energy and Climate Reporter (Brussels, Belgium).
Fellowships, Tours, Grants & Pitch Opportunities.
- Informed Earth is accepting applications from reporters and editors for its new climate journalism training program; apply by November 1.
- The National Institute for Computer-Assisted Reporting is accepting applications for the Philip Meyer Journalism Award, which rewards outstanding work using social science research methods; apply by November 18.
- The New York Times is accepting applications for the Times Fellowship, its yearlong opportunity for early career journalists; apply by November 20.
- Investigative Reporters & Editors is accepting applications for its Data Journalism Bootcamp scheduled for January 11–15, 2027 in Columbia, Mo.; apply by December 6.
CCNow Journalism Awards
Over the coming months, in each edition of this newsletter, we’ll be spotlighting one category from the 2026 Covering Climate Now Journalism Awards. See all the winning work and help us celebrate the winners here.

This week, we’re highlighting winners from the Politics category. In this category, judges considered work covering government action and inaction; policies that hold promise and ones that don’t promise enough; and the leaders who’ve fought to deliver solutions, as well as those who’ve thwarted them.
Alaska for Sale
By Lois Parshley
Grist & Nautilus
The Seed Syndicate
By Cynthia Gichiri with Sam Munia, John Gathuna, Samson Njuru & Kevin Mbugua
Africa Uncensored (Kenya)
Dams: To Build or to Breach?
By Kim Min-wook & Cha Hyun-jin with Park Ju-young, Kim Jun-hyung & Jeon In-je
MBC News (South Korea)
Check out the citations for these winners and find links to their stories here.
